When a business needs new software, whether for accounting, customer management, HR or point of sale, it faces a basic choice. Do you pay a monthly subscription for a service that runs in the cloud (SaaS, software as a service), or do you buy a licence and run the software on your own computers and servers (on-premise)?
Contents
Neither model is always better. The right choice depends on your budget, your internet connection, your IT skills and the kind of data you handle.
What is SaaS?
SaaS applications are hosted by the vendor and accessed through a browser or app. You pay per user or per month, and the vendor handles hosting, updates, backups and security of the platform. Familiar examples include email services, online accounting and video-conferencing tools.
What is on-premise software?
On-premise software is installed on hardware you own or control, whether a server in your office or your own rented servers. You usually pay a licence fee upfront, plus optional annual maintenance, and you are responsible for running it.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | SaaS | On-premise |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Low | High: licences, servers, setup |
| Ongoing cost | Predictable subscription that continues forever | Maintenance, power, IT staff, hardware replacement |
| Speed to start | Hours or days | Weeks or months |
| Updates | Automatic | You schedule and install them |
| Internet dependence | High | Can run on a local network |
| Control and customisation | Limited to what the vendor allows | High |
| Security responsibility | Shared with the vendor | Fully yours |
| Scaling | Add users instantly | May need new hardware |
When SaaS is the better choice
- Small and growing businesses without dedicated IT staff
- Remote or multi-branch teams who need access from anywhere
- Standard processes, such as invoicing or email, where customisation adds little value
- Limited capital, where spreading cost monthly is easier than a large upfront payment
When on-premise may be better
- Unreliable internet at a site where the system must keep running, such as a factory or remote branch
- Strict data requirements, for example where regulations or contracts require data to stay on specific infrastructure
- Heavy customisation or integration with specialised equipment
- Large, stable user numbers where subscription fees over many years would exceed the cost of ownership
Comparing the total cost of ownership
A fair comparison looks at three to five years, not the first month. For SaaS, add up subscriptions, add-ons, extra users and integration costs. For on-premise, include licences, servers, backup systems, electricity and power backup, maintenance contracts, security tools and the staff time to run it all. Our guide to the hidden costs of SaaS covers charges that are easy to miss.
Security: a shared responsibility
A common myth is that cloud software is less secure. Large SaaS providers often invest far more in security than a small business could. But security is shared: the vendor protects the platform, while you remain responsible for user accounts, passwords, access permissions and how staff handle data. Enforcing strong passwords and two-factor authentication is one of the most effective steps you can take.
With on-premise systems, you carry all of the responsibility, including patching, backups, physical security and protection against ransomware.
Data protection considerations
If you process personal data, such as customer or employee details, Kenya’s Data Protection Act, 2019 applies whichever model you choose. Ask SaaS vendors where data is stored, how it is protected and whether they will sign a data processing agreement. Our guide to the Data Protection Act for small businesses explains your obligations.
The hybrid option
Many organisations mix both: cloud email and collaboration tools alongside an on-premise system for a specialised operation. Some vendors also offer “private cloud” versions hosted on dedicated infrastructure.
Questions to ask any vendor
- What is the guaranteed uptime, and what happens if you miss it?
- How are backups made, and how quickly can data be restored?
- Can we export all our data in a usable format if we leave?
- Does the system work offline, even partially?
- What support is available, in which time zone, and at what cost?
Frequently asked questions
Is SaaS always cheaper?
It is usually cheaper to start. Over many years with many users, on-premise can sometimes cost less, but only if you account for every running cost honestly.
Can I move from on-premise to SaaS later?
Yes, though data migration takes planning. Choose systems that let you export data in standard formats to keep future options open.
Featured image: Fans wires back computer server by Unknown via Rawpixel, CC0 (public domain).